Tag Archives: mentoring

Introduction to “Benchmarks”

In this week’s post is the introduction to a mini-book that I have been working on. The subject of the mini-book is mentoring and discipleship and, specifically, how do you measure the effectiveness of mentoring and discipleship within a Christian community or a mentor/ mentee relationship. I am in the process of formatting the work into a pdf that will be available for free download on this blog in about a week.

Introduction to Benchmarks: How Do You Measure the Effectiveness of Mentoring?

This mini-book was birthed out of almost a year of thought. It began as a Bible study I taught to a group of college students over Colossians 2:6-7, the text we will examine closely in this book. It then morphed into a blog post that was featured on the website of LifeWay Christian Resources’ Threads Media and the Baptist General Convention of Texas’ Collegiate ChurchLife Network. From there, the ideas and principles tossed and turned in my mind over the subsequent months. My plan was to put these ideas on paper in order to implement them into the mentoring and discipleship program that I hoped to begin at the church where I served as College Minister.

However, I never had the chance to implement any of these ideas. After just a year as a college minister, a new Executive Pastor decided that the position was not needed and cut it. With that, the idea was placed on the backburner, so to speak. But I decided that even if I could not use the ideas at this point, I would make them available for others to read and incorporate as they see fit.

This is not an exhaustive book on the subject of mentoring and discipleship- as you might expect since it is less than 20 pages. I am not an expert in mentoring and I admit that I am not even very good at it. However, I know mentoring and discipleship are vital for the Christian life and it is vital for ministers, mentors and Bible teachers to understand what mentoring is, why it’s important and how to do it. Essentially, this is a book written to myself as I studied and thought about how to mentor within our current culture. More than anything, I think ministers, mentors and Bible teachers need help in knowing whether or not they are on the right track as they disciple, mentor and teach.

This book seeks to answer that question. It seeks to examine, by way of Paul’s words in Colossians, five benchmarks that can be used to measure the effectiveness of mentoring and discipleship. I pray that you will find this book, and the ideas within it, helpful. I pray that it will encourage you to start mentoring or continue to mentor. Finally, I pray that it challenges you to mentor better, disciple better and teach better so that this generation will have the tools to mentor, disciple and teach the next generation. With that, let’s jump in and answer the question, “What is discipleship?”

© Ryan Vanderland 2013

How Do You Measure the Effectiveness of Mentoring?

Mentoring is one of the hot-button words floating around student ministries right now. Whether junior high, high school or college, more and more people are realizing that one on one relationships are vital for the mental, emotional and spiritual health of students. Within a college ministry context, Chuck Bomar has written extensively on the necessity of mentoring relationships with college students. In his book, College Ministry from Scratch, Chuck outlines only two measures of effectiveness within college ministries as we help them “move toward Christlikeness.” The first measure of effectiveness is “helping individuals process their age-stage issues.” Age-stage issues are issues related to identity, intimacy and truth. The second measure of effectiveness is “cultivating quality relationships between college-age people and old, maturing believers.” I agree with Chuck Bomar that both of these can measure the effectiveness of college ministries, but how can we tell if our mentoring (or what Christians have historically called discipleship) is really having an effect on the students within our ministries? How do we measure the effectiveness of mentoring?

            While reading through Colossians recently, two verses jumped out at me and have become my basis for measuring the effectiveness of mentoring and discipleship. Paul writes to the church atColossaein order to refute a heretical teaching that sprung up within the church; he does this by continually exalting the name and identity of Christ (as in 1:15-20). Paul begins chapter 2 of Colossians by describing how he has fought for these believers to come to a “full assurance of understanding… [of] Christ, in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge” (2:2-3). Like Paul, this is my prayer for the college students at the church and on the campus where I serve. I want them to understand who Christ is and that in Him and Him alone are hidden the treasures of wisdom and knowledge. But how does that happen? How do we mentor students toward this end? I believe Paul tells us in Colossians 2:6-7.

            In those verses Paul writes: “Therefore as you have received Christ Jesus the Lord, so walk in Him, having been firmly rooted and now being built up in Him and established in your faith, just as you were instructed, and overflowing with gratitude” (2:6-7). In this two verses, Paul outlines five benchmarks to help us evaluate how well we are helping students achieve a full understanding of Christ. I’ll sketch each of these very briefly.


  1. Have our students received Christ Jesus as Lord? Before a student can grow toward a full understanding of Christ they first have to begin a relationship with Christ.
  2. Are our students walking in Him? I believe the first stages of discipleship with a new believer should cultivate this daily walking with Christ. This happens by teaching them how to pray, how to read the Bible and how to let Christ rule in their hearts. These are I things I need reminders of all the time and I’m sure our students do as well.
  3. Are our students firmly rooted? When I asked the college students at my church what they wanted from our college ministry, one thing that kept coming up as important was to provide two necessary foundations. First, a biblical foundation. They want to understand the full narrative of Scripture and how it all fits together. Second, a place of security and acceptance with the community of believers. If everything falls apart they want to know that they are rooted into the community of the church. As we mentor, we should work to ground students within the two pillars of the Bible and the community of the church.
  4. Are our students being built up in Christ and established (strengthened) in their faith through instruction? Are we teaching in a way that builds them up in Christ and in their faith? Do we allow students to wrestle with doubt as they work to own faith for themselves? Are we showing through our teaching, as well as our actions, that students can rely fully on Christ? This is the step where students begin to see the world through the eyes and heart of Christ; where they begin to discover the treasures of wisdom and knowledge and understanding in Christ, which Paul mentioned in the previous verses.
  5. Are our students overflowing with gratitude (thankfulness)? When our student are overflowing with thankfulness for who Christ is and what He has done in their lives, they cannot help but love others, encourage others and tell others about the treasures of Christ. Then the cycle can repeat again as others decide to put their faith in Jesus Christ. 

 This semester I am praying Colossians 2:6-7 over my students. I am praying that students who had not received Jesus as Lord would, I am praying that those who are Christians would walk with Him, I am praying that those who are walking with Him would become rooted in their faith, I am praying that those who are rooted would be built up in faith and that after being built up that they would overflow in gratitude in works of service. Will you commit to praying for these as well? As we begin to see students taking these steps of growth, we will know that they are indeed growing toward a full understanding of Christ.


© Ryan Vanderland 2012